Advertising

Hello and welcome!  The past two weeks, we have been talking about advertising in different forms, for different products, and targeting different people and markets.  We began by talking about the city of New York's attempt to get people to try to drink less soda and the effectiveness of their ad.  Here is the ad once again from the New York Times:

As mentioned, the city also released a commercial form of the same ad:




Which one do you think is more effective?  Why?  Let me know your opinion by participating in the poll on the right or leave a comment!